Returning to the office – what's the impact on hiring?


Scaling Success

Insights into executive hiring for scale-ups and entrepreneurially-driven companies.

Hi Reader,

Many senior executives have been talking to me about the return to office (RTO) debate.

It's an emotive subject – and understandably so.

Only recently, UK retail veteran Stuart Rose (ex-CEO for Marks & Spencer, Ocado and Asda) added fuel to the fire over working from home when he said the practice is creating a generation “not doing proper work”. He went on to say he believes “productivity is less good if you work from home”

The financial services sector has pushed for staff to be back in the office for several years, and just recently, JP Morgan called time on working from home.

Amazon and the advertising group WPP are other high-profile employers with an RTO mandate. By contrast, Spotify, has heavily pushed its 'Work from Anywhere' programme, arguing work isn't somewhere you go; it's something you do.

JP Morgan and WPP's CEOs state, respectively, that "We do our best work when we are together in person" and that "Being together greatly enhances mentoring, learning, brainstorming, and getting things done."

It seems rational enough to think that building a high-performance culture is more likely through significant face-to-face interaction.

But removing flexibility, which is seen as a perk, is a big call on the part of employers. Large organisations must be confident that the backlash from employees will be outweighed by productivity improvements. There is also presumably a belief that they can still attract the same calibre of people had they retained hybrid working practices.

Interestingly, there may be less impact on the younger generations who have greater aspirations to be office-based for social as well as professional reasons. The significant impact could be on more senior managers and leaders.

But are many of these RTO decisions qualitative assessments or CEO preferences rather than based on hard data?

◾️ Office-based working was hard-wired in most companies before the pandemic turned working practices on their head overnight.

◾️ Working remotely for most of the week has become engrained in expectations post-pandemic. I didn't expect it to come full circle.

In the context of executive search, my questions and observations are:

💡Is hiring a more qualified candidate who works remotely a better outcome than hiring someone less capable who is in the office four or five days a week?

💡 Are we looking for a different profile of leader within companies with a strong RTO mandate that can create the environment to bring people back to the office?

💡 Companies will always strive to hire the best candidate, but how much does remote working impact leadership effectiveness—hence, performance?

💡 What are the consequences for companies' attrition rates by enforcing RTO mandates? There must surely be an acceptance by larger employers of short-term pain for longer-term gain.

💡 Larger companies with strong employer brands will fare better than small companies that historically struggle to attract people.

💡 With wellbeing such a prominent part of employer brands today, how will companies approach the spectre of regular, long commuting times?

Hybrid working models, without question, open a larger leadership talent pool. Most leadership roles can function effectively this way. I accept there are inevitably exceptions, but the majority of smaller to mid-sized companies will be worse off adopting an RTO policy as it will make hiring considerably harder than it may already be.

There isn't a clear answer to this. We all value flexibility, and as Spotify and JP Morgan demonstrate, companies are at both ends of the spectrum.

To your success,

Guy Day

BartonRock's recent articles & posts

9 Executive Hiring Tips For CEOs in 2025

9 recommendations I’ll be making to my clients at the start of 2025 and serve as something of a high-level leadership hiring audit.

The Impact Of C-Level Job Misalignment

The time, energy, and cost of hiring senior executives are significant, and there is understandable scrutiny around ROI.

How To Keep Your Best Talent In a Competitive Market

What your people truly aspire to see is a compelling digital vision that guides and inspires them in their roles.

About BartonRock:

Guy Day is the Founder of BartonRock, the executive search partner for high-growth companies in consumer and retail.

For more information visit: www.bartonrock.com or contact guy@bartonrock.com

Looking for support in Leadership Effectiveness?

Speak to our sister company NewlandRock led by Kate Thomas. Focused on Assessment | Executive Coaching | Wellbeing Solutions – Internationally


3-5 College Street, Nottingham, Nottinghamshire NG1 5AQ
Unsubscribe · Preferences

Hi, I’m a creator

Read more from Hi, I’m a creator

Scaling Success Insights into executive hiring for scale-ups and entrepreneurially-driven companies. Hi Reader, I have met some great salespeople throughout my career. I've hired many for my clients – indeed sales leadership is a core part of my offering to consumer and retail businesses I have also been CEO for several international recruitment businesses where hiring sales leadership is fundamental to success. At the core of a high-performing sales leader is an innate drive and...

Scaling Success Insights into executive hiring for scale-ups and entrepreneurially-driven companies. Hi Reader, During 25 years in the search industry, I've witnessed significant shifts in how companies and candidates perceive purpose and values. If I rewind to 15 or 20 years, I encountered cynicism towards the importance of purpose and values. However, they have moved from the periphery to a central role in today's company culture. But how important are purpose and values in executive hiring...

Scaling Success Insights into executive hiring for scale-ups and entrepreneurially-driven companies. Hi Reader, After nearly three decades in executive search, particularly within the consumer and retail sectors, I’ve witnessed firsthand what separates a mediocre shortlist from an excellent one. Here are some key insights to consider when crafting a leadership shortlist. 1. Three core considerations When evaluating potential leaders, there are three critical factors to assess: Capability: Can...